Injustice 3 wishlist: Character Rankings & Story Picks

The strongest Injustice 3 wishlist begins with the characters that define the series. Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman, and The Flash form a recognizable foundation, while Harley Quinn, Joker, Aquaman, and Green Lantern maintain the franchise’s signature DC identity. These characters should return with revised mechanics rather than simply repeating their previous versions.

The fan discussions surrounding a possible third game consistently favor a familiar core mixed with riskier additions. That balance matters because a roster built only around Batman-related characters could feel narrow, while a lineup without the Justice League’s main icons would lose the identity that makes Injustice recognizable.

Video Highlights:

• A large fan roster separates essential returns from experimental additions.
• Beast Boy, Plastic Man, and several Teen Titans are emphasized as high-interest picks.
• The proposed DLC lineup mixes DC characters with external guest fighters.
• Story roles and moveset variety are treated as important as popularity.

New characters should earn their place through gameplay identity, story relevance, or both. Beast Boy is one of the clearest examples. His transformations could support multiple ranges and attack patterns without making him feel like another gadget-based fighter. A gorilla, tiger, snake, or bird-inspired toolkit would give him a visual and mechanical profile unlike the existing roster.

Plastic Man offers a similar opportunity through elastic attacks, unusual hitboxes, and comedic animations. Red Tornado could bring aerial movement and wind-based zoning, while Aqualad could provide a new interpretation of water manipulation instead of copying Aquaman’s trident-focused style.

Beast Boy and Plastic Man are especially valuable because they answer a common roster problem: several characters can share a broad archetype even when their stories differ. A well-designed transformation or elasticity system would make these additions feel meaningful rather than cosmetic.

The same principle applies to characters such as Terra and Static. Their inclusion should not depend only on popularity. Each needs a clear combat hook, a strong super move, and enough story material to justify the development space.

A third Injustice game would benefit from a villain who changes the scale of the conflict. Trigon is a strong fan proposal because his connection to Raven naturally links the Titans, Justice League Dark, and the wider DC universe. He also provides a threat that feels different from another version of tyrannical Superman or a standard Batman rogue.

That does not mean the story should abandon the personal conflict that defined the earlier games. Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, and Harley Quinn still offer the strongest emotional contrasts. A larger supernatural or multiverse threat should pressure those characters into temporary alliances rather than erase their existing disagreements.

Several fan concepts also suggest bringing back characters who died in earlier stories. That approach can work if the resurrection has a clear cost or consequence. A return should not simply undo a previous sacrifice. The Black Lantern concept, for example, could create a conflict around whether a revived character is truly restored or being used as a weapon.

A multiverse storyline should also be handled carefully. It can justify unusual matchups and legacy skins, but too many alternate versions may reduce the impact of the main timeline. The best structure would use the multiverse as a pressure point while keeping the primary Injustice continuity at the center.

The most effective DLC lineup should expand the game’s identity instead of functioning as a second main roster. Fan proposals include Rorschach, Booster Gold, Nightwing, Invincible, Red X, Power Rangers, Ben 10, and Mortal Kombat characters. These ideas vary widely, but they share one useful quality: each could introduce a different tone or combat concept.

Rorschach would fit the darker side of the universe, while Booster Gold could add time-travel humor and future technology. Nightwing would satisfy a long-standing demand for a refined staff-and-escrima fighter. Invincible would represent a natural superhero guest, although his inclusion would require careful attention to tone and violence.

The most convincing DLC approach would combine two established DC characters, one unusual comic or animation guest, and one crossover fighter. That structure gives longtime fans familiar requests without making every expansion predictable.

A useful fan wishlist should separate personal favorites from realistic roster priorities. Start with the characters you believe the series needs, then identify the fighters who would introduce new mechanics. Finally, connect your selections to a story arc so the list feels like a potential game rather than a collection of names.

The community discussion at TRMK’s Injustice 3 Wishlist thread shows how broad the possibilities can become. Suggestions range from Plastic Man and Killer Croc to Saint Walker, Vixen, Martian Manhunter, and multiple Mortal Kombat guests. That variety is useful, but ranking the ideas prevents the list from becoming unfocused.

Use the following priority order when refining your list:

• First, lock the essential icons and major story characters.
• Second, add fighters who create new gameplay situations.
• Third, select villains who widen the conflict beyond familiar Gotham rivalries.
• Fourth, reserve DLC slots for legacy characters, unusual guests, or crossover surprises.
• Finally, remove characters whose only purpose is to duplicate an existing moveset.